V12 OR V15? DECISIONS, DECISIONS! Greg Diamond The good folks at Radio Computing Services (RCS) have pushed their Windows-based Selector Version 15 for a number of years now. They have found the task difficult at times, particularly when trying to convert longtime DOS-based Version 12 users.
The reasons for the reluctance to change are as much a testament to the outstanding functionality of V12 as to any negative backlash to V15. Let’s look at them both to help you decide whether to bite the bullet and make the move to the Windows package or stay with your present version.
Selector DOS has powered the majority of the industry for a long time now. Its success has been based on its logical design; its outstanding in-program help files; previously unrivaled feature list, its overall speed, and the fact you have likely used it seemingly forever.
The few downsides include the fact it is only slightly configurable, there have been no recent major improvements and none planned, and it is no longer available to new clients.
With V15, it appeared for a while that RCS may have made an unaccustomed error. In many ways the program was too big and diehard V12 users balked at the steep learning curve. The program, however, is chock full of cutting edge features that will ultimately make scheduling and data management much more precise and flexible.
Other pros and cons include a myriad of new “bells and whistles” in all areas, it is far more configurable than V12, and the Windows platform makes for a comfortable, familiar and easy working environment.
The biggest downside is speed… or the significant lack thereof. There have been rumours for quite some time that a switch in database technology will greatly improve 15’s performance. As it is now, though, the software is a resource hog and should be run on a 3 GHz or higher processor with at least 1GB of RAM. The RCS gang will argue that it will run on a much less robust computer and the fact is it will. However, to do so would be counterproductive with the capital expense saved being quickly overshadowed by operating and manpower costs. Further, a 17” or preferably a 19” monitor should be purchased to allow for the often enormous amount of information viewable, especially in the Log Edit screen.
The other major complaint is the difficult transition from Version 12. V15 is much bigger and progressive and can be very intimidating for those used to previous versions. There’s no magic fix here. The only thing to do is roll up the sleeves and start messing around. Also, the difference between 12 and 15 is such that an open mind will aid in getting you through the initial learning curve. It should be noted that RCS did arranged 15 in a similar fashion to 12, but the change in operating environment negated most of the designers’ good intentions.
For those happy with their tried and true Version 12, go ahead and keep doing what you’re doing. However, keep in mind that RCS has made it clear they will continue to phase it out.
For those who feel they could take advantage of the new features in 15, get the program and start exploring. A word of warning, though, it is much more difficult to learn the new version when you are still using the old one on a daily basis.
For those that have never used Selector and are deciding whether to go with 12 or 15, it is recommended to go with the new one. It will be far easier to learn the program fresh than to unlearn keystrokes/options/habits that may not translate from 12. Also, unless you were to hold RCS up for ransom, it is unlikely they would let you get your hands on the old program anyway.
Admittedly, these are broad stroke observations. ByrnesMedia consultants are recognized experts on Selector and its companion program Linker. We would be happy to discuss the finer points with you to help decide what’s best for you and your application. Feel free to call us anytime. |